Sunday, 30 September 2012

How to... Self Evaluation.


What Role(s) did you take on in the group?
Design was split equally although some were more lengthy than others, there were 5 different products to design and so we designed one each. I took on a leadership role organizing what needed to be done, giving out time frames for both the brief and the presentation.

How well do you think you preformed in the role(s)?
I think I performed very well, I finished the initial design of my product (without backing card) a couple of days before deadline as I was keen to get started. Later adding the instruction card to further improve the product.
Took on the leadership role well, everything managed to get done and everyone knew what they were doing in the presentation.

How well do you think you worked as a group?
I think we worked well, we all managed to work well together listening to each others ideas and managing to agree. Good communication between group members. Everyone chipped into the project. The only downside was people's work ethos began to lag once we had finished the design and moved onto the oral presentation.

What were the positives of working in a group?
Sharing the workload!
Having the idea/ choice to bounce ideas off of one another.
Using each other for research as the project was aimed at students.
More ideas from higher volume of people.
Everyone had different skills to bring to the table.


What were the negatives to working in a group?
Sometimes not being able to get across something you really wanted to say or do. Feeling like you have to wait for others. I had asked group members on a couple of occasions to do some personal work at home and the next day to no avail it had not been completed. I didn't particularly want to take on the leadership role, i prefer equality but at times I felt like I had no choice, and therefore had to end up telling people what to do. 


What will you do differently next time?
Right from the start share out responsibility.
Know how to use illustrator so I don't have to ask others for help.

Where could you have improved your resolution.
Show our research more- collect more evidence from more people and not just our group of 5.
Shared out the speaking more in the oral presentation.
create a more interesting presentation.

What were the strengths of your presentation?
Everything got finished.
Informative and easy to understand.

Covered every aspect of the kit in detail. 
research behind the lifesaver card.

The design concept - illustrations, camo etc. 
having the actual kit made in person and not only as a slideshow.

How to... Progress crit. Peer Feedback.

Comment on how clearly the problem has been identified and understood.
Understood the How to, Produced USEFUL products/ info.
The problem was identified and understood clearly. They understood what the how to was and started to create their ideas around it.

Comment on how well the problem has been analysed and researched.
Good research into itunes card, clubcard etc.
Considered what students need + and what to include in the bad. good analysis.

Researched Itunes & clubcards to inform their discount card .
They didn't research any of the other product designs they created.


Comment on the proposed solution to the problem.
Wide range of solutions. Very interacting + solution can actually be used.


Comment on the clarity with which the information was presented.
Well presented and organised but rest of group could have chipped in.
(I lead the presentation)

Informed well about what they were doing and why. Print outs would have been better than images on an iphone screen.

After the repetitive nature of talking about research into cards, the itunes card etc, I began to think It would be better for the design if, the lifesaver card, came with a piece of card that would inform students how to sign up for the card online. I decided to take some inspiration for this from the itunes card. redeeming online and placing the instructions on the back of the card. 

Here is the final design I made to go with the lifesaver card.


How to...

Our first Brief...
On day one of the briefing process we were put into 11 groups consisting of 4-6 people in each. I was in group 7. In our groups we had to make a list of 100 issues/ problems a student, who lives in Leeds and goes to LCA encounters.
Out of this selection, as a group, we picked what we thought was out favourite 10. We then rotated these lists clockwise through groups, from then we were presented with another groups top 10, from which we had to pick 3. Every groups top 3 were then put into a hat, and one issue was picked out at random for each of the 11 groups. From the issue we received we had to develop the problem into a How to...
this slowly and scarily became our first studio brief, which we had to combat In a way that would appeal to and Intrigue our target audience.
_________________________________________________________

'How to survive when your maintenance loan is late'

What is it?
A survival kit containing tips to save or spend less, A 20% lifesaver card that can be used in supermarkets, Vitamins to help those who can't afford to buy fresh produce through freshers, as well as some 'grow your own loan seeds' which actually contain tomato or apple seeds, alongside a packet of typical student food, super noodles.

Who needs to Know? 
Students who are waiting for their maintenance loan/ whose loan is late.

Why do they need to know?
To keep them from starving/ having no money to spend on food. To prevent struggle arising with necessities like food. 

What do they need to know?
Useful tips on how to save money/ spend less, that they are entitled to 20% off food and drink at any participating  store. 

What is the tone of voice?
There is a comical and informal tone with a advisory and structured undertone.

How will you know Its working?
Will we record the numbers of cards given out to the amount that are registered online. And also take an estimate of students borrowing from the LCA student borrowing fund before and after the kits are given out.
____________________________________________________________

Our concept

After answering these critical questions and bouncing ideas between one another I came up with the idea of creating a 'survival kit' that would house more than one product in order to attempt to solve these issues. This seemed like a good starting point as the kit would include products that students could constantly interact with instead of something they would solely read and throw away. We began to wonder what would help students out most whilst waiting for their maintenance loan. Our final ideas were:
1. To create a flyer that would present students with what we (as our own audience) would consider to be the best tips for saving/ spending less.
2. To provide them with our own brand of multivitamins that would act as a substitute for nutrients in the first couple of weeks in case students can not afford fresh produce.
3. A discount card to save money in supermarkets.
4. A packet of super noodles (typical student food)
5. Some 'Grow your own loan seeds', our own apple and tomato seeds for students to grow their own fruit.
all placed into a canvas bag that we will hand out at a freshers fair.

______________________________________________________________

The Design Process

The first thing that we did was create a running theme that we could use throughout all products in the kit, therefore in the time that we spend separately working on the brief, that when we return to the group, the designs would still relate to one another.
The first idea I pitched is that we should have a consistent theme of camouflage incorporated into the design, creating a semantic link between 'survival' and the products inside the kit. To develop on this idea Adam Garbutt decided it would be a good idea to put some hand drawn illustrations that epitomize a students life, on top of the camouflage. These would be scanned into illustrator and vectorised at a later date. 



This is the camouflage pattern we as a group chose to use in our design.




Some Initial sketches that I (Sarah Goldthorpe) came up with.


Jake Sketching up some ideas, of which we used for the final design.


This is the two designs combined to create the signature texture that we will incorporate into each product.

With each member of the group having the design in hand and on hard drive each of us took on a different product from the survival kit. Adam was assigned the bag, Lizzie the flyer, Jake the multivitamins, Melissa the seeds and for myself the lifesaver card.

Research

When thinking about what product I could put in the survival kit that would improve a students life whilst waiting for their maintanence loan, I began to think about and research into what discounts students are offered. So as an outcome I could focus on what area lacks support for students. 
Visiting the nus website (http://www.nus.org.uk/en/nus-extra/discounts/) I found there were discounts available for the following, 10% off at a range of retail stores (Acessorize, topshop/topman, burton and asos, further discounts are available with nus extra) 5% off at amazon.co.uk, discounted tickets at alton towers and thorpe park, aswell as a 16-25 railcard and educational discount at apple. 
I found that there was a gap in the market when It came to discounts available on food and drink. There are offers for students who hold nus extra cards to gain discount at restaurants such as frankie and benny’s (http://www.nus.org.uk/en/nus-extra/discounts/2011/frankie-bennys-student-discount/) and Pizza hut (http://www.nus.org.uk/en/nus-extra/discounts/2011/pizza-hut-student-discount/). But there were no actual discounts for students buying their own food in super markets. With students having more of a reliance on going out to clubs and purchasing alchohol I thought It would be a good idea to create something that enthused students to food shop, or help them to save during this hard and fustrating time.
I then started to research into a number of cards that have been created in order to gain discount off any purchases. 
1. NUS Card - Regularly used by students as it allows an immediate discount from purchases between 10 and 20% in a range of stores.
2. The tesco clubcard - available for everyone to use. This card offers a points collection scheme, e.g collect 150 points (1 point per pound spent) then recieve a £1.50 voucher to spend in store or on some of the services tesco offer. Your clubcard also records the items you buy and sends you offers regarding products you have purchased or purchase regularly. 
(http://www.tesco.com/clubcard/clubcard/what.asp)
3. HMV Rewards card - Purehmv is a card similar to the tesco clubcard - not specific to students and open to the public. It goes along with the same kind of reward scheme, collectable points, to redeem thigns such as gig tickets, cd’s, posters, digital music and personalised gifts.
(http://pure.hmv.com/search?q=credit&searchsubmit.x=12&searchsubmit.y=8&searchsubmit=Search/)
We found during the research as being our own demographic audience that we could reflect ideas of f eachother. When discussing the Idea of a card, a discount card that would be somewhat equivalent of the NUS but for supermarkets seemed lsike the best option. When students find themselves in the situation where their maintanence loan is late there are in need of an immediate way in which they can save money. The idea of saving points seemed to prolonged for the immediacy needed. 

The lifesaver is a card created for students, that can only be used alongside an NUS I.D card as proof of student status. The card entitles the holder to 20% off any food and drink at the participating stores.  (Tesco, Morrisons, Sainsbury’s and Asda). With the average student shop costing between £10 and £30 a week (statistics taken from our group adding our budgets together and finding the average) with and average of £23, it seemed a better save to create a saving of 20% rather than 10%. Students also don’t have to worry what procucts they are purchasing as it is applicable for any food and drink and is still available alongside other offers. 



Using the texture above that Adam had layered up in illustrator I began to design the card, cropping the design to a card shaped, containing the designs I though were most appropriate when thinking of students.
I then played with fonts adapting Komika axis and code bold, which the rest of the group then used for their font choices. Komika Axis has the properties of a general comic book font, soft and slanted with an informal tone, Code bold dilutes this with its rounder bowls and counters and more vertical spines. Both typefaces write solely in capitals. I then played with the use of black bars as borders in order to accentuate the design and title. The back of the card breathes simplicity, simply black with a white bar for signature, encorporating the same camo colour scheme. Also consisting of a simple message on how to use the card in store and logos demonstrating what stores are involved (these are owned by the companies, they are not designed by me).
This is the final design I came up with for the card.
Adam suggested that we add a barcode to the bottom of the card to make it easier to use.

Following Are the designs that Lizzie created for the flyer, Jake Created for the vitamins, Adam created for the bag and Melissa created for the seeds.


Lizzy's design for the flyer.


Vitamin label design by Jake.

Bag Design by Adam.
Seed Packet Design by Melissa.


Here Is the survival Kit all put together ready for Progress Crit!